As a Raiders fan, I really wanted to like director David O. Russell‘s “Madden,” but this is a surprisingly mediocre and uninspired movie treatment of a football legend. What should have been an entertaining look at one of the most beloved figures in NFL history feels more like a made-for-TV puff piece, complete with corny moments, excessive sentimentality, and a sad, desperate need to make everyone look good. The film reduces John Madden to a loud, cartoonish caricature, never getting beneath the larger-than-life personality to show us the man himself.
Nicolas Cage is a big part of the problem. Buried under heavy makeup, an unconvincing blonde wig, and a ridiculous fat suit, he never quite disappears into the role. Instead, he spends much of the movie doing a distracting, overly theatrical impression of Madden, turning him into a slapstick buffoon. On the other hand, Christian Bale is terrific as Al Davis, nailing the look, attitude, and mannerisms of the famously eccentric Raiders owner. Unfortunately, his performance is stuck in a movie that doesn’t deserve it.
The script is just as disappointing, essentially ticking off career milestones without offering much insight into Madden’s personality, personal struggles, or flaws. His legendary partnership with Davis gets the glossy treatment, while his transition from coaching to broadcasting and the creation of the blockbuster Madden NFL video game empire are rushed through as if the filmmakers are simply trying to stuff everything into the timeline. The pacing is all over the place, and there’s very little sense of what actually made Madden such a fascinating and influential figure.
For someone with such an extraordinary life and legacy, John Madden deserves a much better movie. This one is overly polished, painfully superficial, and far too busy celebrating its subject to bother getting to know him. Even Raider Nation loyalty has its limits.
By: Louisa Moore